How Do Disney World Resorts Compare To Shades of Green In Price? • Military Disney Tips Blog

Special Info:

Planning a Disney World vacation is a big undertaking!

One of the biggest decisions price wise that you’ll have to make during your Walt Disney World vacation planning will be where to stay.

Should you stay at a Disney World Resort using the Disney Armed Forces Salute, or at Shades of Green the Military Owned and Operated Resort on Walt Disney World property?

(Updated March 2020)

There are many factors which will influence your decision. Factors such as: ambience, being immersed in the Disney experience 24/7, convenience/Disney benefits, transportation, and most of all, price.

This post will mostly focus on price, but I’ll explain some of these other factors as we go along as some of them do affect your final price.

Shades of Green

Price Comparison Charts

I’ve put together these price comparison charts to give you a good visual representation of how Shades of Green’s rates compare to Disney’s Moderate and Value Resorts.

The charts are based upon Shades of Green’s standard rates. While Shades of Green does offer discounted rates and packages at various times of the year, I have not taken these into account because once released, Shades of Green constantly changes the dates, offerings, and prices of their discounts and cancels them, all with no notice!

The charts below are based upon:

Disney’s 2020 Armed Forces Salute discounted rates*. The Salute discounts are:
- Disney Value Resorts – Up to 30% Off Rack Rates
- Disney Moderate Resorts – Up to 35% Off Rack Rates
Shades of Green’s FY 2020 and FY 2021 rates
Standard Rooms at both Resorts

*Note, starting in 2018 the Disney Armed Forces Salute room discount rates are not a set 30 or 35 percent off. They are “up to” the 30 or 35 percent off. This means that depending on your dates you might receive a lower discount amount; the only way to know what your price will be is to call (or have your Travel Agent do it for you).

The chart shows how much Disney’s prices fluctuate during the week and emphasizes that Monday through Wednesday night stays are preferred for the best savings at Walt Disney World’s Resorts.

While Shades of Green’s standard prices are the same every day of the year, Disney’s pricing year is divided into many different price seasons.

You will see that the Disney prices go way up during Spring Break when the Armed Forces Salute is not available and on 19 December when the 2020 Armed Forces Salute ends.

Disney rates shown are plus tax with the full Disney Armed Forces Salute room discount applied. there is no tax on Shades of Green’s rates.

Shades of Green’s rates go up on 1 October with the next fiscal year’s rates.

Disney’s Pop Century Resort

Daily Rate Chart

This chart illustrates how Disney’s rates fluctuate not only by season, but by day as well. Friday and Saturday nights are almost always the most expensive and Thursday and Sunday are at an intermediate rate much of the year. Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and sometimes Thursday and Sunday are the cheapest.

This chart is most applicable to shorter stays. You can see the spikes in Disney prices for the higher priced days of the week and high plateaus when the Salute discounts are not available.

Shades of Green’s Category 1 – Shades of Green is cheaper than the Disney values except mid-week during about a third of the year. For the Moderates Shades is always cheaper.

Shades of Green’s Category 2 – Shades of Green is cheaper than the Values only on weekends and when Salute discounts are not available. For the Moderates Cat 2 is cheaper except mid-week in January and February.

Shades of Green’s Category 3 – Disney Values are almost always cheaper. Disney Moderates are more expensive except mid-week in January and February.

Weekly Rate Chart

On this chart I show the average room price for a Sunday to Saturday stay. This is how Disney will show your room price, averaged for your stay length. This smooths out the spikes and averages the weekly highs and lows.

This chart is more applicable for those with longer stays at Disney World.

Disney’s Moderates are more expensive than all Shades categories except Category 3 in January and February. Category 2 is just slightly less in February.

Disney’s Values are cheaper than Categories 2 and 3 about half of the year and only occasionally for Category 1.

Other Factors That Affect Price and Scheduling

Transportation

For those flying to their Disney World Vacation, Disney provides free transportation via their Magical Express from Orlando International Airport to your Walt Disney World Resort Hotel.

Those staying at Shades of Green must obtain their own transportation at their own cost.

Military Disney Tips has negotiated a Military Discount on Airport Transportation

For those driving to their Disney World Vacation, Parking is not free!

Resort Parking

Walt Disney World Resorts charge a nightly parking fee. This fee is based upon the resort category:

Value Resorts $15 per night
Moderate Resorts $20 per night
Deluxe and Disney Vacation Club Resorts $25 per night
The Fort Wilderness campground is still free
Valet parking at all resorts that offer it is $33 per night

Those staying at Shades of Green will pay $11 per night to park their car at Shades of Green and $16 for valet parking.

Theme Park Parking

Theme park Parking is free for Walt Disney World Resort Guests.

Those staying at Shades of Green will pay $25 per day to park at Disney World’s parks. You can take both Shades’ and or Disney’s free transportation service instead of driving to the parks though.

You’ll need to factor these extra costs into your overall Shades of Green cost estimate if applicable.

Disney Amenities – Scheduling

Advance FastPass Plus Reservations – Both Walt Disney World Resorts and Shades of Green Guests may make advance FastPass Plus reservations 60 days prior to check in.

Extra Magic Hours – Both WDW Resorts and Shades are eligible.

Package delivery to your resort from the theme parks and Downtown Disney – Both WDW Resorts and Shades are eligible.

Charge to your room privileges – Disney resort guests at all Disney locations, Shades of Green guests, only at Shades of Green.

Magic Bands – Shades Guests will not receive free magic Bands (only Disney Resort guests do). You may buy your own from the Disney Store or a WDW giftshop after arrival. Shades guests may then use their bands for their theme park admission, FastPass Plus returns, and PhotoPass but not for room key or room charges.

Walt Disney World Room View Categories - Do They Matter at Value and Moderate Resorts?

Disney’s Caribbean Beach Resort

Details

The Resorts quoted are standard view rooms (the cheapest) at Disney’s Caribbean Beach Resort and Disney’s Pop Century Resort.

Price quotes for Disney resorts were obtained from the disneyworld.com website, the applicable maximum Disney Armed Forces Salute discount was subtracted, and then hotel taxes added back in (12.5%.

The Moderates are fairly similar in price, with about $10-30 a night variance. The Fort Wilderness Cabins which also fall under the Moderate Discounts are quite a bit more.

The Value Resorts have three different price levels, the All Stars are the cheapest, followed by Pop Century, and then Art of Animation Suites. The Art of Animation Little Mermaid rooms are not eligible for the Disney Armed Forces Salute room discounts.

Wrapping It Up

These charts are not meant to be used to figure your actual costs, rather as a visual guide to how Disney World’s fluctuating resort prices relate to Shades of Green’s constant rates at different times of the year.

They also just show the cost for the room, no extra charges.

You will need to do a cost comparison including all charges for your dates to see what will be cheaper for you.

See our posts on how the 3 Disney Resort categories compare to Shades of Green in all respects:

You can see what other military families think about Shades of Green in our Shades of Green Survey Results.

Call Disney or my recommend travel agent, Ears of Experience for a Disney Resort quote or for more information.

Kudos to my friend Dave from yourfirstvisit.net for the inspiration for these charts. His numerous, fantastic and very through ones cover many aspects of non-military discounted prices and better yet, both crowds and when to go to Disney World.

If you are planning a Disney World Vacation, when will it be? Let us know in the comments section below!

Planning a Disney Trip? Want to get the best military discounts that are available? Feeling a little confused? Get Our Email Newsletter

Read about the Temporary Changes to Disney World during their Post-Lockdown Re-Opening

See Our Great Disney Discount and Planning Info:

Learn about the Disney Armed Forces Salute the best military discount that there is for Disney. See our Topic Overview Pages:

Resorts/Hotel Overview Page
Dining Overview Page
Transportation Overview Page
Technology Overview Page
Shades of Green, WDW’s Military Only Resort

Disney Guidebooks By MDT

Military Disney Tips' Recommended Disney Travel Agent

Ears of Experience Disney Only Travel Agency. Military family owned and operated! They know all the ins and outs of Disney military discounts!

SaveSave

Comments

Patricia Payne says

31 January 2014 at 07:03

Steve (and co) thank you so much for offering this information. I have visited Disney World the past two years during marathon weekend. Both visits included a resort stay at Shades of Green and were both adult only trips. We had the lower rate that Shades offers and their beautiful amenities to enjoy. We weren’t too worried about AFS renewal-if it wasn’t renewed we would enjoy a park free trip focused on Shades, our race day events and Disney bonuses like the Boardwalk. However, we have decided to make the next trip a family affair. Our four children, 5-15, all have to train for an age appropriate race to “earn” their Disney trip. I never even thought of the repercussions of not having AFS tickets. Thank you for the reminder…I think this afternoon would be well spent designing a second “just in case” budget! Can’t imagine being that close to the magic and telling the kids they couldn’t actually go inside!! Thank you for your dedication to this site and all of our military brothers and sisters.

- Steve says
  
  31 January 2014 at 17:38
  
  Hey there Patricia,
  
  I just love the training to earning their trip! So awesome.
  
  I know what you mean about being so close with the kids. Our kids are out on their own now so we have many “just us” trips and we have been so many times we don’t have to do a park. There are so many other things to do. That will change when we have grand kids 😉
  
  I’m very confident we won’t have to worry about not having a discount. THe only issue is people being able to get the room they want, ADRs and FP+s in that first quarter
  
Kristen says

7 July 2014 at 16:42

I’m wondering about travel time to each of the parks. Do you know approximate travel times and best/recommended mode of travel to each from Shades? I know some resorts use buses for certain parks but recommend car for say the water parks and AK.

Thanks in advance!

- Steve says
  
  7 July 2014 at 16:55
  
  Hi Kristen,
  
  It is about a 6 minute ride from Shades to the Transportation and Ticket Center. From there a 8 minute monorail ride to Epcot. For the Magic Kingdom it would be a 10 to 15 min monorail or ferry ride. These times do not take into account any waiting for the Kristen to arrive.
  
  You can take the 10-15 min walk from Shades to the Polynesian and catch the 5 min monorail ride to the MK.
  
  Hollywood Studios is about a 10 minute ride and Animal Kingdom is about 15.
  
  Did you see my Shades transportation page? http://www.militarydisneytips.com/Shades-of-Green/Shades-of-Green-Transport.html
  
Peg P says

10 October 2017 at 16:51

I suppose it depends on what time of the year you visit Disney. On my reservation, the cost of Sunday night is the same as that for both Friday and Saturday nights. Thursday is cheaper, but still more than Monday through Wednesday.

- Steve says
  
  10 October 2017 at 17:39
  
  That’s right Peg, it’s not always a hard and firm Fri/Sat higher rate. This is often caused by 2 different price seasons intersecting or a 3-day long weekend bump in the prices.