How Do Disney World Resorts Compare To Shades of Green In Price?

Planning a Disney World vacation is a big undertaking!

One of the biggest decisions price wise that you’ll have to make during your Walt Disney World vacation planning will be where to stay.

Should you stay at a Disney World Resort using the Disney Armed Forces Salute, or at Shades of Green the Military Owned and Operated Resort on Walt Disney World property?

(Updated Dec 2020)

There are many factors which will influence your decision. Factors such as: ambience, being immersed in the Disney experience 24/7, convenience/Disney benefits, transportation, and most of all, price.

This post will mostly focus on price, but I’ll explain some of these other factors as we go along as some of them do affect your final price.

Price Comparison Charts

I’ve put together these price comparison charts to give you a good visual representation of how Shades of Green’s rates compare to Disney’s Moderate and Value Resorts.

The charts are based upon Shades of Green’s standard rates. While Shades of Green does offer discounted rates and packages at various times of the year, I have not taken these into account because once released, Shades of Green constantly changes the dates, offerings, and prices of their discounts and cancels them, all with no notice!

• Find Your Shades of Green Price Category and Regular Room Rate
• Check For Shades of Green Discounts (Note: during the reopening period after the virus shutdown, there are no discounts)

The charts below are based upon:

• Disney’s 2021 Armed Forces Salute discounted rates*. The Salute discounts are:
  • Disney Value Resorts – Up to 30% Off Rack Rates
  • Disney Moderate Resorts – Up to 35% Off Rack Rates
• Shades of Green’s FY 2021 and FY 2022 rates
• Standard Rooms at both Resorts

*Note, starting in 2018 the Disney Armed Forces Salute room discount rates are not a set 30 or 35 percent off. They are “up to” the 30 or 35 percent off. See more detail on this practice. This means that depending on your dates you might receive a lower discount amount; the only way to know what your price will be is to call (or have your Travel Agent do it for you).

Our charts shows how much Disney’s prices fluctuate during the week and emphasizes that Monday through Wednesday night stays are preferred for the best savings at Walt Disney World’s Resorts.

While Shades of Green’s standard prices are the same every day of the year, Disney’s pricing year is divided into many different price seasons.

You will see that the Disney prices go way up  on 19 December when the 2021 Armed Forces Salute ends.

Disney rates shown are plus tax with the full Disney Armed Forces Salute room discount applied. there is no tax on Shades of Green’s rates.

Shades of Green’s rates go up on 1 October with the next fiscal year’s rates.

Daily Rate Charts

Here we show 2 different charts, the first indicating the maximum Disney Armed Forces Salute discounted rates, the second shows no discount at all for the Disney World rates just for comparison

These charts show how Disney’s rates fluctuate not only by season, but by day as well. Friday and Saturday nights are almost always the most expensive and Thursday and Sunday are at an intermediate rate much of the year. Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and sometimes Thursday and Sunday are the cheapest.

These charts are most applicable to shorter stays. You can see the spikes in Disney prices for the higher priced days of the week and high plateaus when the Salute discounts are not available.

Here is a what the Salute discount chart shows for the indicated Shades of Green Price Categories:

Shades of Green’s Category 1 Guests – Shades of Green is cheaper than the Disney Value Resorts for about a third of the year and on weekends the remaining portion of the year (green line vs dark blue line). Shades of Green is always cheaper that the Moderate Resorts (green line vs red line)

Shades of Green’s Category 2 Guests – Shades of Green is cheaper than the Values only on weekends about a third of the year and when Salute discounts are not available (purple line vs dark blue line). For the Moderates Cat 2 is cheaper except mid-week in January and February (purple line vs red line).

Shades of Green’s Category 3 Guests  – Disney Values are almost always cheaper except about a quarter of the year and even when Shades of Green is cheaper on weekends, it is only by a few dollars (light blue line vs dark blue line). Disney Moderates are more expensive except in January and February (light blue line vs red line).

Below we show the same chart this time without any discount military or otherwise just the show the difference.

But keep in mind even when the Disney Armed Forces Salute is not available there are often general public ones that are 5 to 10 percent less than the Salute would be.

If no discount is available, Shades of Green is always the cheaper choice except for Category 2 and 3 on weekdays in January and February, and Category 3 a few weekdays in November and December.

Weekly Rate Chart

On this chart I show the average room price for a Sunday to Saturday stay. This is how Disney will show your room price, averaged for your stay length.

When you put your dates to get a quote from Disney, each night of your trip often has a different price. Disney shows you the average of all nights.

This method smooths out the spikes and averages the weekly highs and lows and is easier to make a comparison. This is because while there might be a couple nights of your trip where you would pay way more with Disney, the rest of the cheaper nights at Disney makes Disney cheaper overall.

This chart is more applicable for those with longer stays at Disney World.

Disney’s Moderates are more expensive than all Shades categories except Category 3 in January and  February. Category 2 is just slightly less in February.

Disney’s Values are cheaper than Categories 2 and 3 about half of the year and only occasionally (Jan, Feb, Nov) for Category 1.

Other Factors That Affect Price and Scheduling

Transportation

For those flying to their Disney World Vacation, Disney provides free transportation via their Magical Express from Orlando International Airport to your Walt Disney World Resort Hotel.

Those staying at Shades of Green must obtain their own transportation at their own cost.

For those driving to their Disney World Vacation, Parking is not free!

Resort Parking

Walt Disney World Resorts charge a nightly parking fee. This fee is based upon the resort category:

• Value Resorts $15 per night
• Moderate Resorts $20 per night
• Deluxe and Disney Vacation Club Resorts $25  per night
• The Fort Wilderness campground is still free
• Valet parking at all resorts that offer it is $33 per night (Valet Parking is currently Unavailable)

Those staying at Shades of Green will pay $13 per night to park their car at Shades of Green. (Valet Parking is currently Unavailable)

Theme Park Parking

Theme park Parking is free for Walt Disney World Resort Guests.

Those staying at Shades of Green will pay $25 per day to park at Disney World’s parks. You can take both Shades of Green’s and or Disney’s free transportation service instead of driving to the parks though.

You’ll need to factor these extra costs into your overall Shades of Green cost estimate if applicable.

 Disney Amenities – Scheduling

Disney Genie Individual Attraction Selections – All guests can participate in Disney Genie, Disney Genie+ and in app charge Individual Attraction Selections. But for the Individual Attraction Selections, guests staying at Select Disney Resorts will be able to purchase their attractions at 7 a.m. the day of their visit, while others will have to wait until they enter a park. Disney has not yet said what “Select” Resorts, but I assume it will be Deluxe Resorts and Deluxe Villa Resorts, AND possibly Moderate Resorts. Whether any on property non-Disney resorts will be included is not yet known.

Disney Genie Announcement

Starting in October 2021, Disney Resort guests including Shades of Green guests will be eligible for the new Early Entry & Extended Evening Hours that replace Extra Magic Hours. These guests may both enter every theme park early, and stay on select days at select Walt Disney World theme parks.

Early Entry & Extended Evening Hours

Package delivery to your resort from the theme parks and Downtown Disney – Both WDW Resorts and Shades are eligible. (Package Deliveryg is currently Unavailable)

Charge to your room privileges – Disney resort guests at all Disney locations, Shades of Green guests, only at Shades of Green.

Magic Bands – Shades of Green Guests will not receive the ability to purchase discounted Magic Bands as part of their reservation (only Disney Resort guests do). You may buy your own from the Disney Store or a WDW giftshop after arrival. Shades guests may then use their bands for their theme park admission and PhotoPass but not for room key or room charges.

Details

The Resorts quoted are standard view rooms (the cheapest) at Disney’s Caribbean Beach Resort and Disney’s Pop Century Resort.

The Caribbean is a typically priced Moderate. Pop Century is prices slightly more than the All-Star Resorts, but the All-Stars have not yet reopened and pricing is not available from Disney.

Price quotes for Disney resorts were obtained from the disneyworld.com website, the applicable maximum Disney Armed Forces Salute discount was subtracted, and then hotel taxes added back in (12.5% at all Disney resorts except the All-Stars which would be 13.5%).

The Moderates are fairly similar in price, with about $10-30 a night variance. The Fort Wilderness Cabins which also fall under the Moderate Discounts are quite a bit more.

The Value Resorts have three different price levels, the All Stars are the cheapest, followed by Pop Century, and then Art of Animation Suites. The Art of Animation Little Mermaid rooms are not eligible for the Disney Armed Forces Salute room discounts.

 Wrapping It Up

These charts are not meant to be used to figure your actual costs, rather as a visual guide to how Disney World’s fluctuating resort prices relate to Shades of Green’s constant rates at different times of the year.

They also just show the cost for the room, no extra charges.

You will need to do a cost comparison including all charges for your dates to see what will be cheaper for you.

See our posts on how the 3 Disney Resort categories compare to Shades of Green in all respects:

• Shades of Green – Disney Value Resort Comparison
• Shades of Green – Disney Moderate Resort Comparison
• Shades of Green – Disney Deluxe Resort Comparison

You can see what other military families think about Shades of Green in our Shades of Green Survey Results.

See these Posts and Pages to learn more about Disney’s Resorts:

• Walt Disney World and Disneyland Resort Categories and Room Types
• Walt Disney World Resorts
• Walt Disney World Room View Categories – Do They Matter at Value and Moderate Resorts?
• Walt Disney World Resort Guest Benefits
• Walt Disney World Resort Theming

Call Disney or my recommend travel agent, Ears of Experience for a Disney Resort quote or for more information.

Kudos to my friend Dave from yourfirstvisit.net for the inspiration for these charts. His numerous, fantastic and very through ones cover many aspects of non-military discounted prices and better yet, both crowds and when to go to Disney World.

If you are planning a Disney World Vacation, when will it be? Let us know in the comments section below!

SaveSave